The title of the article is “Yes, We Could .. Get Out! Why We Won’t Leave Afghanistan or Iraq.” It is a satirical article that lists many reasons why the US will not leave Afghanistan or Iraq, but presents them in a way that shows how they are usually reasons to leave anyway. I’m not sure if this article is entirely truthful, but at least in my opinion it is written from a more unique point of view.
The article starts out simply, with Yes, we could. The author, Tom Engelhardt argues that we could easily withdraw the huge number of troops from Afghanistan and Iraq. There are almost 200,000 thousand soldiers deployed in those two countries, and that doesn’t include the massive numbers of defense contractors or otherwise who are also present. The article insists that we “undoubtedly withdraw them all reasonably quickly and reasonably painlessly.” This is something I find a little bit hard to believe, but the article continues on methodically picking at arguments that we have all heard at one time or another about the current war situation. The first reason is that after spending more than 8 years in Afghanistan and at least two in Iraq, leaving would be a danger to the planet itself. Without the guidance of America, Iraq and Afghanistan would succumb to the people who had been ruling them before. The United States occupation of Iraq has changed what was once considered ‘an advanced country in the Arab world’ into a disaster zone.’
Similarly, while regularly knocking off Afghan civilians at checkpoints on their roads and in their homes, at their celebrations and at work, we ignore the fact that our invasion and occupation opened the way for the transformation of Afghanistan into the first all-drug-crop agricultural nation and so [it becomes] the planet's premier narco-nation.
Many of these situations are spelled out for the reader to see the effect of the invasions of both Iraq and Afghanistan. After many ‘solutions’ that were brought to Afghanistan and Iraq by the USA, the article makes its first good point; the reality that our stake in Afghanistan is minor. Afghanistan is one of the poorest nations on the planet. It is also relatively far from the US, almost on the other side of the world. What kind of importance could it hold to citizens of the United States? Knowing these facts, the United States has been involved with Afghanistan (and fighting there) on and off for 30 years. One counter argument to this is that without helping Afghanistan to rid itself of organizations like al-Qaeda will migrate to Afghanistan and plan attacks all over the world. The article says that many Americans believe that Afghanistan was the safe haven necessary for terrorists to come up with the idea to attack the World Trade Center. Many people have forgotten that the World Trade Center was almost bombed in 1993, and that attack was planned somewhere in New Jersey.
These are the main points that I thought were important in the article. The tone of the article did not bode well with me, and I believe that the author is generalizing too much. One of his arguments for withdrawal is that America was able to deploy its troops quickly to a hostile region, so why isn’t it possible for us to remove them just as fast. The answer to that is obvious, because we have been there for a long time and it is easier to bring assets to somewhere than to remove them. Deploying troops at combat readiness is an important thing for any army, and one of the most important parts of our own. There isn’t a strategic need for rapid withdrawal as there is for rapid deployment of troops. Either way, I do not believe that we should simply drop everything and leave Iraq and Afghanistan. I am unsure if our departure from Iraq would hurt the country more than it would help, but at least Afghanistan is on the path to recovery, even though it may be rocky, it is still heading in the right direction.
No comments:
Post a Comment