Wednesday, March 31, 2010

US Intelligence not up to proper standards in Afghanistan

Major General Michael Flynn says that US Intelligence in Afghanistan is not useful for the war. A report by US Army intelligence chiefs says that foreign newspaper articles about Afghanistan are more useful than the information collected by United States soldiers in the field. Major General Flynn and two other intelligence advisers report that the ‘huge intelligence apparatus’ in Afghanistan is only marginally relevant to the coalition war effort. This is mostly due to the fact that army intelligence is concerned with finding members of the Taliban to kill or capture. The intelligence that the army should be concerned about are the needs and ill-treatment of Afghan citizens. As I’ve said many times in this blog the war must be won in the hearts of the people and this is exactly the kind of change that is needed.  According to the Guardian (UK newspaper) the support of ordinary Afghan citizens is now seen as the key to victory over the insurgency. The report says that US army intelligence officers are “ignorant of local economics and landowners, hazy about who the powerbrokers are and how they might be influenced, incurious about the correlations between various development projects and the levels of co-operation among villagers.” The report continues, “Some battalion-level officers looking for an overview of the political and economic situation in key areas acquire more information that is helpful by reading US newspapers than through reviewing regional command intelligence summaries.” To be honest, I’m not sure I’m surprised by this information. Considering the language and cultural barriers between the United States and Afghanistan it makes sense that human intelligence is hard to get, especially for members of the military. One could argue that their job is to do exactly that, but the other part of the problem is that this kind of intelligence may not be perceived as very useful from a military standpoint. Many soldiers die from IED explosions and other insurgent activities and intelligence forces are more concerned about finding those responsible than winning the hearts and minds of the local people. I would argue that it is more productive in the long run to understand ordinary civilians to prevent future attacks. (I am not a military strategist nor am I a historian or any person qualified to make such arguments so please let me know if what I’m saying makes no sense at all.)
An excellent argument made by General Flynn is that “merely killing insurgents usually serves to multiply enemies rather than subtract them"
The above statement could not be more accurate. Another part of the problem may be closer to home; the Obama administration and senior US politicians may not want the kind of ‘nonmilitary’ intelligence that is needed to understand the people of Afghanistan. The US commander of Nato forces in Afghanistan, Stanley McChrystal is quoted saying that American’s war leaders are not getting the information they require  and that instead the ‘media is driving the issues.’ I believe that this report is right on the mark and sums up exactly what needs to be changed. This kind of frank report may be an oddity now days and it is excellent to see a report that criticizes the norm while also providing a logical solution. Finally the report calls for a “culture change in the intelligence community” where they will forego their loved Power Point slides for “meaty, comprehensive descriptions of pivotal districts throughout the country” typed up on word processors.

"Analysts must absorb information with the thoroughness of historians, organize it with the skill of librarians, and disseminate it with the zeal of journalists," the report says.


US Intelligence at its best

Sunday, March 28, 2010

Things Don’t Look Good for Afghanistan

At the recent University of South Florida symposium on Afghanistan and Pakistan many experts say that things in Afghanistan are not looking good. The war in Afghanistan has gone on for almost nine years, and at this point there is no guarantee of success.  A professor at the Naval Postgraduate School in Monterey, Calif says that he is a pessimist about the state of things in Afghanistan.
"I'm a pessimist about where we are now, where we've been and where we're going," 
By April of 2010 Afghanistan will become the longest conflict that the United States has ever been in, making it longer than the Vietnam War. The people at the USF Symposium are not very proud of the direction that the war has been going, and even after nine years there is still debate about which direction to take. Ronald Neumann, former U.S. ambassador to Kabul, said the simplest definition of success in Afghanistan would be “a government that had popular support and could sustain itself without dependence on foreign troops.” This is a very reasonable goal in my personal opinion and I believe that it was the one that the Bush administration was hoping to reach. Unfortunately things have not gone according to plan and now popular opinion wants a realistic (and quick) way to leave the war in Afghanistan. The goal of success in Afghanistan is unreachable, according to Neumann, if the Obama administration tries to push for social and political changes in Afghanistan. Troop withdrawals and major legal changes cannot happen properly in only 18 months. Neumann served in the Bush administration from 2005 to 2007 and says that the
"The lack of realism in the U.S. is leading to demands in Afghanistan that are not only unrealistic but may be dangerous,"
He continues, "To expect that the fourth-poorest nation on earth, with high illiteracy and an education system being rebuilt from near total destruction will produce an effective and efficient government in another year or two is wishful thinking." This could be an extremely simple way to put the demands expected for success in Afghanistan into words. Afghanistan has very many illiterate people and a very poor economy, and expecting it to change so much in such a short time sounds like a very unreachable goal. According to this article (http://www.commondreams.org/headline/2010/03/25-5) one of the major reasons that the war has been going o for so long is that the new government headed by Hamid Karzai is extremely ineffective. The Taliban (disliked by 94% of Afghans) have been able to fill in the gaps of the new government, even after being expelled from positions of authority back in the beginning of the war in 2001. The Taliban have been able to make up for local services in outlying towns when the government is too inefficient or too corrupt to help. The Taliban cannot be beaten by simply fighting a war because the people of Afghanistan need to choose to reject them. Another important point to take away from the symposium is that the strategy of reconciliation with former Taliban leaders is “unluckily to succeed” according to Thomas Johnson, the professor from the Naval Postgraduate School. He says,
"It's a mistake to think of the Taliban as just insurgents - I think that the ones that really matter are jihadists. Much more so than is recognized in the (Washington) Beltway, is that people are joining the Taliban for ideological reasons."
I believe this is an important point because many people believe that the Taliban is full of people who are all suicide bombers or some sort of terrorists. The Taliban is still around in Afghanistan because people approve of them on a small level. The people who join are idealists and not terrorists. To achieve ‘success’ in Afghanistan is to win the war in people’s hearts, not just in their minds.

Thursday, March 25, 2010

A Small Piece of Democracy in Afghanistan?

The current government of Afghanistan is not able to take proper care of all the villages all over Afghanistan. The absence of formal government calls upon the traditional council of elders, the shura, but what are people to do when a shura is not present? Villages took it upon themselves to create village development councils to decide the development affairs of their own villages. Critics of the war on Afghanistan in the United States say that it was a mistake for western countries to bring something as different as democracy to a country as underdeveloped as Afghanistan. New news shows that even if the federal government is unable to work, villages all over Afghanistan are benefiting from local democracy. Afghanistan has a National Solidarity Program (NSP) that finances small projects chosen by village development councils all over the country. The NSP helps to finance things like water pumps, small dams, and hydroelectric power generators all over Afghanistan. The idea behind the program is that local villages know their own needs better than far away ministries and foreign agencies. The program has annual audits where books are checked publicly and councilors are subjected to questioning by other villagers to ensure that funds from the program are not misused. Last April the NSP spent around $593 million, which averages to about $33,000 per village per year. The system is extremely popular, so much so that some villages run out of funding. Some found other sources to petition for further projects, such as foreign NGOs (Non Government Organizations), or even pooling resources as a community.


Villagers in Behre Kamal in the Baghlan province of Afghanistan raised $16,000 to build a mosque, while in Markaza Khinjan the local village council launched women’s education classes. The council’s chairman says, “We’re not just spending the government’s money. We’re planning for our future,” beaming with pride. Local councils have been expanding their responsibilities to include ones abandoned by the government. Many official institutions in Afghanistan are paralyzed by corruption and incompetence, so it is not hard for the villages to fill in. In one case a large estate’s owner died and the family was divided over the inheritance. The relatives tried to get the district court to help (which was a three hour drive each way) settle the dispute. The case dragged on endlessly, and the judge had demanded bribes from both parties. Finally, the family turned to the village council who happened to be the only party they could trust. “This is better than a faraway court. We live here, we know these things better,” explains Mahmad Azar, Behre Kamal’s council chair.

This is good news for Afghanistan and I hope that there are more and more stories like this. Widespread local democracy is one of the best ways to get the entire society to realize how beneficial it can be and will hopefully lead to widespread adoption by many Afghans.

Source: http://www.economist.com/world/asia/displaystory.cfm?story_id=15772771

Thursday, March 18, 2010

Pakistan arrests a Taliban Deputy Leader

New news! Pakistan wants a say in how the ending of the war in Afghanistan plays out. Pakistan’s concerns are valid because it has to worry about a rapidly developing India to the east, changing relations with Iran to the west, and growing Indian influence in Afghanistan to the north-west. Pakistan recently captured a deputy leader of the Taliban, Mullah Abdul Ghani Baradar and some of his high-ranking comrades. Pakistan used the arrest as a way to reinitiate a “strategic dialogue” with the United States. The delegation of Pakistanis will be lead by their foreign minister and includes the chief of the army and the head of the ISI (Inter-Services Intelligence – the Pakistani equivalent of the CIA). The dialogue is going to cover many different issues from helping Pakistan’s economy to more determined issues such as civil nuclear technology. One of the most urgent topics is the future of Afghanistan. The economist believes that Pakistan’s ISI may try to use the arrest to take control over the Taliban’s old negotiating position as the former Taliban deputy leader (Baradar) had been making overtures directly to Afghanistan. 

The capture of Baradar is a double victory for Pakistan. They successfully captured a Taliban official who had become troublesome, and proved to NATO and the Afghan government that they were willing to crack down on the Taliban. In the past, Pakistan had not been cracking down on insurgency leaders, and they were hoping to win praise for their actions. Instead of being praised for their actions Pakistan has been criticized. Some reports say that Afghanistan’s president, Hamid Karzai, is angry that his favorite Taliban has been locked up. India, Iran and Russia are reported to be unhappy that Pakistan is trying to control the direction of Afghanistan’s future.

Pakistan’s own position on the matter has changed for the better. Instead of choosing only the Taliban as its best hope for a friendly Afghan government, Pakistan’s lawmakers would prefer an Afghan based government with  some Taliban elements brought in to bright both sides together. Pakistan wants links with non-Taliban people in Afghanistan. America has a much stronger line than its allies when  dealing with the  insurgency; such as allowing insurgent commanders to defect and work with coalition forces instead of talking to the Taliban leadership. Afghanistan itself is wary of Pakistani interventions into matters concerning Afghanistan. Polls show that ordinary Afghans resent Pakistan for interfering in the affairs of Afghanistan.

Will any good come out of these new directions? I’ll be sure to report on whatever happens.

See you next week


source: http://www.economist.com/world/asia/displaystory.cfm?story_id=15731374

Thursday, March 11, 2010

AfPak Diary - Day One

This entry sums up my thoughts on a journalist's recount of a three day trip from Peshawar, Pakistan to Bamiyan, Afghanistan. The author is unnamed, so he is referred to simply as 'the author' throughout the blog.

The first day was spent browsing through a bazaar with active traders and busy people rummaging around trying to find buyers for their wares. The author even says that many shopkeepers recognize foreigners with a grin and a, "How are you mister?" This peaceable setting is very different from the image that most people think of when they think of Afghanistan and Pakistan. However, right around the corner is a large building with its entire front blown out, with fresh debris on the street. A local explains that there was a suicide bomb the day before, and that many people died. He says that there is a new attack every week, and that “they slaughter us even in the bazaars now.” They refers to different people according to Dr. Naveed Irfan. He says that ‘they’ mean Blackwater operatives, because they never go to recover bodies. The actions of Blackwater in Iraq and Afghanistan are not commendable, but maybe there is some sort of reason why they left those bodies. Dr. Ifran continues on about Osama bin Laden, “I met him once. Al-Qaeda is not a terrorist network. It is a conspiracy by the Americans to destabilize our country.” Apparently Pakistani newspapers and TV channels broadcast the same theories regularly. A lack of education and public suspicion and distrust hurt the image of the west throughout the Middle East. I wish that all people around the globe were able to understand each other, so that these kinds of misconceptions could be seen as pure disinformation that they are. If people were able to understand each other, I feel that there would be no more fighting around the world, but enough of that train of thought.


Look at all the neighbors!


Moving on, the author describes why he decided to take a three day journey across the AfPak border:

In recent months, international attention has been concentrated on the open warfare waged in southern Afghanistan’s Helmand province. But far from the borderlands around Kandahar, the battle for “hearts and minds” rages on in the other major Pushtun-majority region, the vast area between Peshawar in Pakistan and Jalalabad in Afghanistan. President Barack Obama and every other Western leader involved in the war with Taliban have emphasised the importance of “recognising the fundamental connection between our war effort in Afghanistan, and the extremist safe havens in Pakistan.” I undertook this trip to learn something about that connection.
The battle for hearts and minds is an extremely important part of the war that the United States truly needs to win. Without the support of the people that we have come to help, we are seen as conquerors and a huge disturbance of the peace. In addition, Afghanistan cannot be ‘fixed’ by eliminating all hostile elements inside it, and essentially forcing them to simply move across the border to Pakistan. The border between countries must be patrolled and both parties must be committed to an agreement on security.  One especially amazing event was when the author met with the Taliban, in one of their madrassas (a sort of institution for the higher learning of the Koran). The imam in charge explains that the students have studied the Koran for eight years, and that some have already memorized 6,666 of the verses by heart. One young man asks, “Why are your countrymen trespassing on Muslim soil? Why do they slay our Muslim brothers?” The author explains, carefully, that Americans demanded the Taliban hand over Osama bin Laden after September, 11, 2001, but that we were refused. The young man’s reply:

“Listen,” says the young man, his fierce, proud face framed by a short black beard and a white prayer cap. “We are Pushtun people. We live by the Pushtun code. If your enemy came here”—he gestures towards the sky—“we would protect you with our lives. It is our duty. So it was when the Americans came for bin Laden.” The imam nods, smiling. “The Taliban said, ‘Give us proof, and we shall hand him over.’ But the Americans did not give the Taliban proof. So it is our duty to protect him, as it is our duty to protect you.”

This was not the answer that I was expecting. I expected a defiant answer about a holy war and how American (or western?) culture was destroying the hearts and minds of Islamic people. Instead, the author was met with a reasonable, if not misinformed reply. Again the problem is simply misinformation that has been spread en masse, by both sides. I think that if people had kept their heads clear that these past few years would have been very different.










Article Source: http://www.economist.com/world/asia/displaystory.cfm?story_id=15650433

Thursday, March 4, 2010

Anti IED Technology

Hello again, and welcome to a new blog about the war in Afghanistan. This week's news is about new technology that is being developed to defeat improvised explosive devices in Iraq and Afghanistan. One of the biggest casuses of casulaties for US Soldiers in Iraq are improvised explosive devices (IEDS) and results for over two thirds of coalation deaths. Part of the problem with is the constant struggle between bombmakers and bomb defusers. Increased defusals of IEDs force bombmakers to invent new strategies to create bombs. In addition, the internet and travel have helped different people communicate and collaborate on new bomb designs.
Bomb makers have constantly been upgrading their designs in response to coalation force's efforts to defuse and remove IEDs. Originally coalation forces would use 'garage-door' triggers which basically sent out radio signals to attempt to explode IEDs from a safe distance. Bombers then switched to using cell phone components because they could trigger deatonators from a greater distance. Mobile phone signals can be delayed or jammed, so bombers had to switch again to long range cordless phones. These phones do not use traditional telecom networks so speficic jamming equipment has to be used to counter them. The best jamming kit uses an extreme amount of battery power and costs around $140,000. Jamming is also sometimes counterproductive since it interfears with all electronic communications, so a coalaition force's own communication equipment can be affected. This game of cat and mouse continues between bombmakers and coalation forces with no end in sight. Some bombmakers changed and started using simple devices that do not require electronic signals. Cheap light sensors can deatonate a bomb in a dark room as soon as a door or window is opened. Contact deatonators are simple devices that trigger an explosion when two wires or metal plates are pushed together.


Picture source - the Economist (http://www.economist.com/search/displaystory.cfm?story_id=15582147)
BAE systems is developing a vehicle mounted camera, object recognition software and satellite positioning to create extremely detailed three dimensional maps of roads. These maps would then be compared to current conditions to detect additions such as pot holes, or anything that could be used to hide a bomb. Discovering an IED is just the beginning of the solution; once an explosive is detected it must aslo be defused. Robots can move explosives to remote locations and deatonate them, but they are heavy and costly devices. The constant war between bomb makers and bomb 'defusers' is never ending. Even with new technological developments, bomb makers are able to make simple changes to counteract the newest detection and defusal methods.
I believe that eventually techniques and technology will be able to defeat almost all of the IEDs that could harm coalation forces, but that time is not now. In the very forseeable future however this may become a reality.

Wednesday, March 3, 2010

Hurt Locker Followup

Hello everybody -

Just wanted to follow up on the Hurt Locker. It was a movie that I did not enjoy very much, mostly because I didn't like the main character. The movie follows the day to day lives of a bomb squad operating in modern Iraq after the invasion. A bomb squad receives its best member who happens to be a very cavalier individual who only really cares about defusing explosives. The movie is seen as very 'gritty' and a mostly realistic portrayal of what our soldiers go through in Iraq. There are many times where the star of the movie has to fight with his squadmates to get the job done the way he wants to get it done. He goes into situations ignoring established protocols and defuses a bomb through sheer wit and luck. I admit that my review of the movie is partially biased, since I read  a report from an ex Special  Forces member who was offended by the movie. He said that a man like the main character would never be able to do the things that he does in the movie. Furthermore, he takes offense from the fact that he knew people who were killed in Iraq and they would never do the things that were done in this movie. I think that if the main character wasn't such a cowboy I would  have really enjoyed the movie.


Final Hurt Locker Score - : 7/10
-Main Character is not a  realistic person in the army
-A solid attempt at showing the public what really happens in Iraq
-Plenty of character development, and the movie flows pretty solidly throughout its entire duration.