Sunday, March 28, 2010

Things Don’t Look Good for Afghanistan

At the recent University of South Florida symposium on Afghanistan and Pakistan many experts say that things in Afghanistan are not looking good. The war in Afghanistan has gone on for almost nine years, and at this point there is no guarantee of success.  A professor at the Naval Postgraduate School in Monterey, Calif says that he is a pessimist about the state of things in Afghanistan.
"I'm a pessimist about where we are now, where we've been and where we're going," 
By April of 2010 Afghanistan will become the longest conflict that the United States has ever been in, making it longer than the Vietnam War. The people at the USF Symposium are not very proud of the direction that the war has been going, and even after nine years there is still debate about which direction to take. Ronald Neumann, former U.S. ambassador to Kabul, said the simplest definition of success in Afghanistan would be “a government that had popular support and could sustain itself without dependence on foreign troops.” This is a very reasonable goal in my personal opinion and I believe that it was the one that the Bush administration was hoping to reach. Unfortunately things have not gone according to plan and now popular opinion wants a realistic (and quick) way to leave the war in Afghanistan. The goal of success in Afghanistan is unreachable, according to Neumann, if the Obama administration tries to push for social and political changes in Afghanistan. Troop withdrawals and major legal changes cannot happen properly in only 18 months. Neumann served in the Bush administration from 2005 to 2007 and says that the
"The lack of realism in the U.S. is leading to demands in Afghanistan that are not only unrealistic but may be dangerous,"
He continues, "To expect that the fourth-poorest nation on earth, with high illiteracy and an education system being rebuilt from near total destruction will produce an effective and efficient government in another year or two is wishful thinking." This could be an extremely simple way to put the demands expected for success in Afghanistan into words. Afghanistan has very many illiterate people and a very poor economy, and expecting it to change so much in such a short time sounds like a very unreachable goal. According to this article (http://www.commondreams.org/headline/2010/03/25-5) one of the major reasons that the war has been going o for so long is that the new government headed by Hamid Karzai is extremely ineffective. The Taliban (disliked by 94% of Afghans) have been able to fill in the gaps of the new government, even after being expelled from positions of authority back in the beginning of the war in 2001. The Taliban have been able to make up for local services in outlying towns when the government is too inefficient or too corrupt to help. The Taliban cannot be beaten by simply fighting a war because the people of Afghanistan need to choose to reject them. Another important point to take away from the symposium is that the strategy of reconciliation with former Taliban leaders is “unluckily to succeed” according to Thomas Johnson, the professor from the Naval Postgraduate School. He says,
"It's a mistake to think of the Taliban as just insurgents - I think that the ones that really matter are jihadists. Much more so than is recognized in the (Washington) Beltway, is that people are joining the Taliban for ideological reasons."
I believe this is an important point because many people believe that the Taliban is full of people who are all suicide bombers or some sort of terrorists. The Taliban is still around in Afghanistan because people approve of them on a small level. The people who join are idealists and not terrorists. To achieve ‘success’ in Afghanistan is to win the war in people’s hearts, not just in their minds.

No comments:

Post a Comment