Major General Michael Flynn says that US Intelligence in Afghanistan is not useful for the war. A report by US Army intelligence chiefs says that foreign newspaper articles about Afghanistan are more useful than the information collected by United States soldiers in the field. Major General Flynn and two other intelligence advisers report that the ‘huge intelligence apparatus’ in Afghanistan is only marginally relevant to the coalition war effort. This is mostly due to the fact that army intelligence is concerned with finding members of the Taliban to kill or capture. The intelligence that the army should be concerned about are the needs and ill-treatment of Afghan citizens. As I’ve said many times in this blog the war must be won in the hearts of the people and this is exactly the kind of change that is needed. According to the Guardian (UK newspaper) the support of ordinary Afghan citizens is now seen as the key to victory over the insurgency. The report says that US army intelligence officers are “ignorant of local economics and landowners, hazy about who the powerbrokers are and how they might be influenced, incurious about the correlations between various development projects and the levels of co-operation among villagers.” The report continues, “Some battalion-level officers looking for an overview of the political and economic situation in key areas acquire more information that is helpful by reading US newspapers than through reviewing regional command intelligence summaries.” To be honest, I’m not sure I’m surprised by this information. Considering the language and cultural barriers between the United States and Afghanistan it makes sense that human intelligence is hard to get, especially for members of the military. One could argue that their job is to do exactly that, but the other part of the problem is that this kind of intelligence may not be perceived as very useful from a military standpoint. Many soldiers die from IED explosions and other insurgent activities and intelligence forces are more concerned about finding those responsible than winning the hearts and minds of the local people. I would argue that it is more productive in the long run to understand ordinary civilians to prevent future attacks. (I am not a military strategist nor am I a historian or any person qualified to make such arguments so please let me know if what I’m saying makes no sense at all.)
An excellent argument made by General Flynn is that “merely killing insurgents usually serves to multiply enemies rather than subtract them"
The above statement could not be more accurate. Another part of the problem may be closer to home; the Obama administration and senior US politicians may not want the kind of ‘nonmilitary’ intelligence that is needed to understand the people of Afghanistan. The US commander of Nato forces in Afghanistan, Stanley McChrystal is quoted saying that American’s war leaders are not getting the information they require and that instead the ‘media is driving the issues.’ I believe that this report is right on the mark and sums up exactly what needs to be changed. This kind of frank report may be an oddity now days and it is excellent to see a report that criticizes the norm while also providing a logical solution. Finally the report calls for a “culture change in the intelligence community” where they will forego their loved Power Point slides for “meaty, comprehensive descriptions of pivotal districts throughout the country” typed up on word processors.
"Analysts must absorb information with the thoroughness of historians, organize it with the skill of librarians, and disseminate it with the zeal of journalists," the report says.
US Intelligence at its best
No comments:
Post a Comment