Wednesday, April 28, 2010

Why We're Not out of Afghanistan

Here’s an interesting opinion piece forwarded to me by my history professor. http://www.truthout.org/why-we-wont-leave-afghanistan-or-iraq58869
The title of the article is “Yes, We Could .. Get Out! Why We Won’t Leave Afghanistan or Iraq.” It is a satirical article that lists many reasons why the US will not leave Afghanistan or Iraq, but presents them in a way that shows how they are usually reasons to leave anyway. I’m not sure if this article is entirely truthful, but at least in my opinion it is written from a more unique point of view.

The article starts out simply, with Yes, we could. The author, Tom Engelhardt argues that we could easily withdraw the huge number of troops from Afghanistan and Iraq. There are almost 200,000 thousand soldiers deployed in those two countries, and that doesn’t include the massive numbers of defense contractors or otherwise who are also present. The article insists that we “undoubtedly withdraw them all reasonably quickly and reasonably painlessly.” This is something I find a little bit hard to believe, but the article continues on methodically picking at arguments that we have all heard at one time or another about the current war situation. The first reason is that after spending more than 8 years in Afghanistan and at least two in Iraq, leaving would be a danger to the planet itself. Without the guidance of America, Iraq and Afghanistan would succumb to the people who had been ruling them before. The United States occupation of Iraq has changed what was once considered ‘an advanced country in the Arab world’ into a disaster zone.’

Similarly, while regularly knocking off Afghan civilians at checkpoints on their roads and in their homes, at their celebrations and at work, we ignore the fact that our invasion and occupation opened the way for the transformation of Afghanistan into the first all-drug-crop agricultural nation and so [it becomes] the planet's premier narco-nation.

Many of these situations are spelled out for the reader to see the effect of the invasions of both Iraq and Afghanistan. After many ‘solutions’ that were brought to Afghanistan and Iraq by the USA, the article makes its first good point; the reality that our stake in Afghanistan is minor. Afghanistan is one of the poorest nations on the planet. It is also relatively far from the US, almost on the other side of the world. What kind of importance could it hold to citizens of the United States? Knowing these facts, the United States has been involved with Afghanistan (and fighting there) on and off for 30 years. One counter argument to this is that without helping Afghanistan to rid itself of organizations like al-Qaeda will migrate to Afghanistan and plan attacks all over the world. The article says that many Americans believe that Afghanistan was the safe haven necessary for terrorists to come up with the idea to attack the World Trade Center. Many people have forgotten that the World Trade Center was almost bombed in 1993, and that attack was planned somewhere in New Jersey.

These are the main points that I thought were important in the article. The tone of the article did not bode well with me, and I believe that the author is generalizing too much. One of his arguments for withdrawal is that America was able to deploy its troops quickly to a hostile region, so why isn’t it possible for us to remove them just as fast. The answer to that is obvious, because we have been there for a long time and it is easier to bring assets to somewhere than to remove them. Deploying troops at combat readiness is an important thing for any army, and one of the most important parts of our own. There isn’t a strategic need for rapid withdrawal as there is for rapid deployment of troops. Either way, I do not believe that we should simply drop everything and leave Iraq and Afghanistan. I am unsure if our departure from Iraq would hurt the country more than it would help, but at least Afghanistan is on the path to recovery, even though it may be rocky, it is still heading in the right direction.

Friday, April 23, 2010

Explosive Reactive Armor

One of the more interesting things that I have found while researching different things on Afghanistan was Explosive Reactive Armor. This isn’t a topic specifically about Afghanistan, but it is used on many tanks in different armies all over the world. This entry is going to be about one interesting piece of technology that is keeping our soldiers safe while fighting for our freedoms.

How ERA works - from wikipedia

Explosive Reactive Armor is basically armor that contains an explosive charge between two metal plates. At first, it seemed ridiculous to me that protecting something like a tank would involve strapping explosives to its sides. Explosive reactive armor is basically a slab of an explosive charge sandwiched between two metal plates. If this doesn’t make sense, imagine an ice cream sandwich. The ice cream is the explosive and the cookies are the metal plates. Explosive Reactive Armor (ERA) is placed on the outer armor of a tank and is the first thing to be hit by projectiles. The principles behind its usage are that enemy projectiles hit the outer metal plate of the ERA which detonates the charge inside. The charge expands the armor and effectively repels whatever hit it. This type of armor is very effective in dealing with weapons designed to penetrate armor, as when it is hit by them the force of impact creates a longer path that the projectile has to punch through. Another important design of ERA is that it is angled so that a projectile will never hit it straight on. The incoming projectile must always cut through new material at the time of impact.

 Russian T72 with layered ERA - its the tiny color squares!

ERA is actually not a new development in modern warfare. The Soviet Union was using it to armor its tanks in the 1980s, and even tanks in eastern European military forces have either been modified to use ERA or have had ERA tiles added to them. ERA is not a huge coat of armor or a shield for a tank, but is more like the first line of defense and is only added to existing armored parts of an armored vehicle. Since ERA contains an explosive charge a vehicle must be fortified to prevent damage to the vehicle or its crew when the armor explodes. ERA is usually applied to tanks in the form of small square tiles so they can be easily replaced after they have been expended.



There are other types of reactive armor, but in all of them the principle is the same. Reactive armor changes itself in order to protect the vehicle that it is placed on. There are many types of reactive armor including non-explosive reactive armor, self limiting reactive armor, and even a new experimental type called electric reactive armor which is still being developed. The experimental electric reactive armor uses two conductive plates separated by a conductive material which creates a capacitor. A high voltage power source must charge the armor, so when it is penetrated by an incoming charge it discharges all the electricity stored in the capacitor. This would dump all the electricity into whatever pierced the armor, hopefully destroying it or turning it into plasma.

Still interested? Extra reading at
http://www.militaryphotos.net/forums/showthread.php?42203-ERA-%28Explosive-Reactive-Armor%29-how-it-works
http://defense-update.com/features/du-1-04/reactive-armor.htm

Sunday, April 18, 2010

Congressional Research Service analysis reports that contractor deaths are rising in Afghanistan

ProPublica, an independent online news service has just posted an article about the rising number of civilian casualties in Afghanistan. According to the article 289 civilians have been killed since the war began (almost 9 years ago). One hundred of the 289 contractors killed have died in the past six months. The rise in casualties is partly due to the surge of American troops and contractors who came with them after President Obama decided to increase the number of soldiers present in Afghanistan. This is also a sign of the increasing violence in Afghanistan. Reports from the US Department of Defense show that there are currently more civilian contractors on the ground in Afghanistan than there are soldiers. 107,292 US hired civilian contractors were reported to be in Afghanistan by the Pentagon in 2010 compared to around 78,000 soldiers. This is one of the first times that there has been a significantly higher number of contractors have outnumbered soldiers in a long time. ProPublica says that contractors are an easy way to get needed labor done without raising official casualty figures. Civilian contractors could haul food, prepare meals, and even act as bodyguards without being officially counted as military deaths. This keeps the death count lower than it would have been such as in past conflicts, because so many contractors are being used to help with the war effort. ProPublica continues, saying that contractors are basically ‘invisible to the public’ and they help to conceal the full ‘human cost’ of the wars in Iraq and Afghanistan. If civilian deaths had been counted in the official death toll, then the one for Afghanistan would have passed 1000. 848 soldiers and 289 civilian contractors have died from 2001 to 2009.

After hearing many bad things about American contractors in the Middle East, I must admit that I feel no remorse hearing this news. I believe that private defense contractors are a huge waste of money, and that kind of work simply turns soldiers into mercenaries who are not responsible for their actions in a hostile land. To make matters worse, these men are given military weapons and do not care for the wellbeing of the people they are supposed to be protecting. They are paid more than ordinary soldiers and are not accountable for any mistakes they may make. This is a terrible combination if you ask me. Contractors are also more expensive than the regular infantry. They are paid more by their firms, who have gotten huge billion dollar contracts from the government. If the US government has the people, facilities, and time to train soldiers, why would it spend more money on people who were soldiers and give them freedom to do whatever they want in a foreign country they do not care for? This may be a little bit of generalization, but the situation is very close to the one I have described. With that being said, it is never good when a person dies. Every private security contractor in Afghanistan should consider a career change, or become a beneficial contractor such as a doctor or someone who is able to help repair the considerable amount of damage that has been done by other defense contractors.

Monday, April 12, 2010

Possible Coverup of Deaths of Afghan Civilians

Random Special Forces

The provocative title of this week’s entry comes from an inquiry into the practices of the United States Special Forces in Afghanistan. After nine years of fighting most of the work that the Special Forces have done has been out of the public spotlight. A new high profile investigation is bringing the heat and pointing the public eye in their direction. Both Afghan and American officials are investigating the aftermath of a raid in February carried out by US Special Forces. Five Afghan civilians died in the raid, and it is alleged that their deaths were covered up. The raid was led by US Special Forces and they were backed up by Afghan troops. Three of the five dead civilians were women, and the Special Forces are charged with tampering with the bodies to conceal the way that they died. The US military has accepted responsibility for the deaths on February 12th. (Link here - http://lat.ms/ad1n5d), and even though they had initially blamed the deaths on insurgents, senior officials met with family members of the dead civilians to apologize. The underlying charge that accompanied the deaths of the civilians is that bullets were taken from the bodies of the corpses to cover up their deaths, but United States officials say that they are unjustifiable charges.
There is a new investigation that has just been opened to compare the differences between the findings of the initial American inquiry (classified) and the findings of the Afghan government. This LA times article (http://www.latimes.com/news/nationworld/world/asia/la-fg-afghan-special-forces9-2010apr09%2C0%2C7174357.story) says that US Special Forces are very much linked to civilian deaths and casualties in Afghanistan. Apparently, Special Forces account for a “disproportionate share” of civilian casualties caused by western troops; however, there are no precise figures to prove this point since Special Forces missions are secret. The US commander on the ground in Afghanistan, General Stanley McChrystal believes that Afghan civilian casualties are detrimental to the war effort because they turn the people of Afghanistan away from the help that the United States is trying to provide. I believe he is absolutely right, and the United States cannot keep killing the people of Afghanistan. The bottom line is that killing them obviously makes them unhappy, and the way that the Afghan people see it, they can either be oppressed by the Taliban or killed by the people who were sent to Afghanistan to help them. This is not the case, but I’m sure that some people think exactly that, that they have no options at all.

General McChrystal

Ever since he took command, General McChrystal has changed the rules of engagement in Afghanistan to try and relieve civilian casualties. Special Forces are given more freedom than regular troops due to their mission of hunting down Taliban fighters. The Special Forces have earned an awesome sort of respect from Afghani fighters. Whenever they are spoken of it tends to be in whispers, and they strike fear into the hearts of many would be attackers. That may have been a little bit of creative description, but the Special Forces have earned their names in Afghanistan. They are secretive even among their own comrades and have beards and Afghan looking clothes. The LA Times says that they also ‘react explosively’ if anyone tries to take their picture.
The US military raid in question was supposed to be a simple mission. It was made to sound as if it were a “successful instant of Western raiders swooping down on wanted militants.” NATO (at the time) described the men who were killed as armed insurgents who had fired on friendly troops. They also said that the 3 women were dead before the coalition troops arrived. Two months of investigating changed the story significantly. The two slain Afghan citizens were ordinary civilians; one was an Afghan police official and the other was a district prosecutor. Local leaders identified the two men, and the others were a teenage girl and two pregnant women. The two pregnant women were mothers of a total of 16 children. Canadian Brigadier General Eric Tremblay spoke for NATO saying, "We deeply regret the outcome of this operation, accept responsibility for our actions that night, and know that this loss will be felt forever by the families.” This kind of news really puts the integrity of our own Special Forces into question. Why would they want to kill ordinary civilians? Even if the men had been armed, and even IF they had fired on coalition troops, there is no reason I can think of to kill pregnant women. I am saying this sitting safely at home in my apartment, but it is hard to imagine the circumstances necessary to facilitate the necessity for that kind of slaughter.

The raid occurred on a family compound in the village of Khatabeh and was tampered with to conceal the circumstances of the civilians’ deaths. "By the time we got there, there was a foreign guy guarding the bodies, and they wouldn't let us come near," said Azizdin Wardak, chief of police in Paktia. Reports were made that coalition forces removed bullets from the walls of the compound, collected their casings, and washed the ground. That sounds very much like a coverup, but military officials say that that could also be the legitimate means to reconstruct the events on the night of the raid. An Afghan investigator was quoted by a British newspaper saying that US Special Forces were trying to extract bullets from the bodies of their victims. The unidentified investigator apparently interviewed a relative of the deceased who described a coalition soldier standing over one of the bodies after the raid with a knife. General McChrystal’s spokesperson said there was no forensic evidence or any eyewitness testimony to support the claims of the unknown investigator. So far there had been no official evidence of a coverup, but the incident remained controversial due to the fact that the military suggested that the women had been killed ‘execution-style’ by insurgents or by an ‘honor killing’ by their own relatives. The military had also said that they died at a time not during the raid by Special Forces. There was a large gathering in the family compound, which was mistaken as a gathering of insurgents instead of the simple celebration that it was.
Since the raid General McChrystal has limited night time operations due to the increased chances of false identification of suspected insurgents. Night raids are extremely effective to strike at ones enemy, but many innocent people could be caught in the crossfire. Rural parts of Afghanistan commonly have weapons due to the volatile nature of living out in the country, and especially in a country like Afghanistan. Anyone who hears a gunshot at night would want to defend themselves, and this is a likely cause of many unfortunate civilian casualties over the years.  I think that this is a sound decision and even though it hurts Special Forces operating capabilities it is definitely worth the sacrifice. Preventing the killing of innocent civilians is just as important if not more important than killing the insurgents. The death of innocent civilians should outweigh the death of a few insurgents who are hiding with the civilians.

 Afghan Villager speaks to US Special Forces on Patrol

Many Afghans do not trust the Special Forces after NATO airstrikes have killed many civilians on incorrectly planned attacks. Civilians have been hurt because coalition forces have not followed proper protocols set in place to prevent civilian deaths. In February a NATO airstrike killed 27 people, some of which were women and children. NATO surveillance had observed three vehicles closely following each other heading for Khandahar, the southern city that is regarded by the Taliban as its spiritual home. The small convoy was believed to be an insurgent group preparing to attack coalition forces, but turned out to be only innocent travelers. Killing the people that we went out to protect is a huge issue. I believe the problem is that some people really care about the protocols and understand the need to protect innocent civilians. There are obviously those who do not care enough or care at all about the people that we have come to protect. NATO airstrikes are fine when they’re used properly, properly in this context means against a tactical or strategic target, and more specifically one that is not in a location full of innocent people who would suffer for the bad choices of one single individual.

This is becoming way too long to be a blog article, there’s almost enough information for three blogs here! I hope it wasn’t too boring because it is a topic of deep discussion and one that I believe must be solved in order to help the people of Afghanistan.

Well – until next week.










Source: http://www.latimes.com/news/nationworld/world/asia/la-fg-afghan-special-forces9-2010apr09,0,7174357.story?page=1

Friday, April 9, 2010

Study Results about the Size of Families in Afghanistan

Experts say that Family size and composition have large economic and social consequences in Afghanistan according to experts. While this may not seem like noteworthy news, I find it interesting that a larger family would not be beneficial. In ancient times people have had lots of children for many reasons. Children could be a source of free labor (what my parents always told me ;] ), or help around the house. I believe that people also had many children because infant mortality rates were much higher than they are today. Afghanistan is relatively primitive compared to the rest of the world and one would think that the same logical reasons of the past applied today. The Afghan Central Statistics Office says that the larger a family is the greater its vulnerability to poverty, illiteracy, and food insecurity. The analysis is based on a study from 2008 called the National Risks and Vulnerability Assessment (NRVA) which showed that family size was directly correlated to poverty. Other people believe that a key component of poverty is ‘family composition.’ Families with multiple working age people are better off than families without, and if many of the working age people are male a family is able to cope with difficulty. Obviously a family with many elderly or many children would be more vulnerable to poverty. Another interesting fact of the study is that families headed by women are usually poorer than those headed by men in Afghanistan. There are at least 70,000 households in Afghanistan headed by women according to the study, and most of them are widows. NRVA says that the absence of a male head of household is a sign of the vulnerable position of the household members for both income security and social protection.

Afghanistan has many human rights problems, and poverty is both “widespread and multidimensional in Afghanistan” according to a report by the UN Office for Human Rights. A report posted on March 30th says that there is a huge human rights deficit in Afghanistan, and poverty is both a cause and consequence in the lack of caring/investment in human rights. This is somewhat understandable since Afghanistan is a poor country, and without necessary funds civil programs become less of necessities and more of extraneous items on a state budget. The NRVA says that at least nine million Afghanis live in absolute poverty, which comes out to about 36 percent of the population. Five million other citizens are “non-poor” and live on US $43 a month. Thirty years of war (be it with themselves or other countries), unemployment, poor health care, and lack of education are all causes for the continuing poverty of the Afghan people. Poverty and lack of employment lead many youth to join criminal and insurgent groups due to lack of other options. It appears that once the hole got deeper it could only get deeper. Continuing poverty lead to more and more poverty which meant that there was no money for employers to pay employees and the cycle continues. The Afghan Labor Ministry estimates that unemployment is over 40 percent and many of the eligible to work young men leave the country in search of better opportunities. People in Afghanistan seek protection from the problems that the country has by having large families but in many cases it is not a beneficial solution. A mother of ten children says, “I find it hard to feed my children let alone help with their education, clothing, medical and other expenses,”, whose husband died last year. Two of her eldest sons, Qudratullah, age 16 and Esmatullah, age 15, have stopped their education full time in order to work and help their younger siblings.




Unfortunately poverty triumphs throughout Afghanistan

Rampant poverty throughout Afghanistan is a very serious problem, especially because it cascades like a snowball rolling down a mountain. The only clear solution that I can think of is to inject large sums of money into the country via loans or grants to develop infrastructure. Before that the fighting needs to end, and it could very well be a long time before that happens. 

Monday, April 5, 2010

Karzai threatens to join the Taliban

Hello everybody. I heard about an amusing piece of news that I thought I’d share with everybody. http://www.cbc.ca/world/story/2010/04/05/karzai-kandahar.html
Apparently the president of Afghanistan, Hamid Karzai has threatened twice to quit politics and join the Taliban. His ‘threats’ came after pressure from western powers asking him to make reforms. Apparently the threat was given during a private meeting with Afghan lawmakers over the weekend. Some people from the meeting believe the threats to be specifically aimed at the ‘hardline members’ of the Afghan parliament. It is somewhat understandable since Mr. Karzai is under a lot of pressure from all sides. To be honest, I think that this news is more amusing than anything else, and I hope that it was more of a cynical comment to vent frustration. Unfortunately it seems that this comment is just the latest in a string of comments that have caused Mr. Karzai to be viewed in a negative light by many of his foreign backers. According to CBC news (a Canadian newspaper), just last week Karzai accused the UN and the international community of carrying out a vast fraud as part of a plot to deny him reelection. Robert Gibbs, a white house spokesperson told reporters, “On behalf of the American People, we’re frustrated with the remarks.” Are Karzai’s threats more than words? Is this merely wordplay between the United States and Afghanistan? I cannot be sure, but I hope that the issues that caused this are being talked about, behind closed doors if necessary. Understandably Karzai is very busy and being pulled in all directions, but if he cannot speak to some sort of American official candidly about what really needs to happen then I feel that this whole process is lost.

 Karzai walking with bodyguards in Khandahar

In other news, Karzai visited Khandahar City south of Kabul which has weathered through lots of violence. During one visit to a community where dozens of residents had died in an explosion a few weeks before the Afghan president was sharply criticized for not putting out enough effort to stop the violence. When asked about the upcoming surge of NATO troops, Karzai simply responded, “Our partners are here to help, but we run this country as Afghans.” Afghan civilians are worried about the new troop arrivals even though they are coming to help due to the high number of civilian casualties during strikes against insurgents. The strikes weaken Karzai’s hold of power and boost support for the insurgency since NATO troops are seen as aggressors and not protectors. I understand it is an extremely different situation when you’re in a foreign country and under fire, but hopefully the military can keep minimizing the deaths of the people they’re there to protect. What good is safety when there’s nobody left to keep safe?

Wednesday, March 31, 2010

US Intelligence not up to proper standards in Afghanistan

Major General Michael Flynn says that US Intelligence in Afghanistan is not useful for the war. A report by US Army intelligence chiefs says that foreign newspaper articles about Afghanistan are more useful than the information collected by United States soldiers in the field. Major General Flynn and two other intelligence advisers report that the ‘huge intelligence apparatus’ in Afghanistan is only marginally relevant to the coalition war effort. This is mostly due to the fact that army intelligence is concerned with finding members of the Taliban to kill or capture. The intelligence that the army should be concerned about are the needs and ill-treatment of Afghan citizens. As I’ve said many times in this blog the war must be won in the hearts of the people and this is exactly the kind of change that is needed.  According to the Guardian (UK newspaper) the support of ordinary Afghan citizens is now seen as the key to victory over the insurgency. The report says that US army intelligence officers are “ignorant of local economics and landowners, hazy about who the powerbrokers are and how they might be influenced, incurious about the correlations between various development projects and the levels of co-operation among villagers.” The report continues, “Some battalion-level officers looking for an overview of the political and economic situation in key areas acquire more information that is helpful by reading US newspapers than through reviewing regional command intelligence summaries.” To be honest, I’m not sure I’m surprised by this information. Considering the language and cultural barriers between the United States and Afghanistan it makes sense that human intelligence is hard to get, especially for members of the military. One could argue that their job is to do exactly that, but the other part of the problem is that this kind of intelligence may not be perceived as very useful from a military standpoint. Many soldiers die from IED explosions and other insurgent activities and intelligence forces are more concerned about finding those responsible than winning the hearts and minds of the local people. I would argue that it is more productive in the long run to understand ordinary civilians to prevent future attacks. (I am not a military strategist nor am I a historian or any person qualified to make such arguments so please let me know if what I’m saying makes no sense at all.)
An excellent argument made by General Flynn is that “merely killing insurgents usually serves to multiply enemies rather than subtract them"
The above statement could not be more accurate. Another part of the problem may be closer to home; the Obama administration and senior US politicians may not want the kind of ‘nonmilitary’ intelligence that is needed to understand the people of Afghanistan. The US commander of Nato forces in Afghanistan, Stanley McChrystal is quoted saying that American’s war leaders are not getting the information they require  and that instead the ‘media is driving the issues.’ I believe that this report is right on the mark and sums up exactly what needs to be changed. This kind of frank report may be an oddity now days and it is excellent to see a report that criticizes the norm while also providing a logical solution. Finally the report calls for a “culture change in the intelligence community” where they will forego their loved Power Point slides for “meaty, comprehensive descriptions of pivotal districts throughout the country” typed up on word processors.

"Analysts must absorb information with the thoroughness of historians, organize it with the skill of librarians, and disseminate it with the zeal of journalists," the report says.


US Intelligence at its best