Hi all - been pretty busy so this will be a short entry. I thought this was interesting although it doesn't really relate to the war at all.
Some Iraq, Afghanistan war veterans criticize movie 'Hurt Locker' as inaccurate - is the title of a Washington Post article from today. I have to admit I haven't seen the movie, so I probably should before I pass judgment on this article.Here's a quote from a self identified army ranger who posted on Paul Rieckhoff's facebook page, founder of Iraq and Afghanistan Veterans of America:
"[I]f this movie was based on a war that never existed, I would have nothing to comment about. This movie is not based on a true story, but on a true war, a war in which I have seen my friends killed, a war in which I witnessed my ranger buddy get both his legs blown off. So for Hollywood to glorify this crap is a huge slap in the face to every soldier who's been on the front line."
I can understand his point of view very clearly, and it makes me wonder why the film is about (Iraq? Afghanistan?). If the movie was in an 'unspecified country' or somewhere different from Iraq or Afghanistan would it really satisfy those who are angry at the movie's production already?
I will watch the Hurt Locker and return with an update so I can give a solid opinion on this news. Is Hollywood glorifying war just for profit? Are the soldiers whose heroics have gone unnoticed finally getting some time in the limelight? Tune in next week to find out!
(not really next week.)
Ah - article source: http://www.washingtonpost.com/wp-dyn/content/article/2010/02/25/AR2010022506161.html?hpid=topnews
Friday, February 26, 2010
Thursday, February 25, 2010
131 Children Killed in Afghanistan

131 Children Killed in 2009 NATO air raids
http://www.presstv.ir/detail.aspx?id=119430§ionid=351020403
Found this article while searching using google news. The article says that a new UN report “reveals that over 130 children have been killed in NATO air raids in [Afghanistan] last year.” The article continues and says that 346 children were killed in Afghan violence last year. “131 of these were by aerial strikes, 22 by search and raid by Special Forces; 128 were killed by anti-government elements, including assassinations and suicide bombings,” said Radhika Coomaraswamy, the UN secretary general’s for children and armed conflict. Discussions with ISAF (International Security Assistance Force) and the Afghan army will be done to protect the children when encountered on military operations. Obviously nobody is happy when children are killed, especially in a military operation where they could not cause any harm.
The question that comes to my mind: How many of these children’s deaths could have been prevented? I am very curious, and perhaps the circumstances differ quite a bit, but wouldn’t it be possible to take more care in search operations? I understand that our troops have a lot to go through, and going through foreign territory where almost everything can be perceived as a threat is very complicated. Perhaps a soldier even let a child live, just to have that child pick up a hand gun and attempt to kill (or actually kill) the soldier that had saved him. I’m not sure at all if this scenario ever happened, but when children die it makes you wonder if they could have been saved. This of course comes from someone who hasn’t been to Afghanistan and experienced the conditions there, but it still makes me wonder. As I said before, this war needs to be won in the hearts of the people that we’re trying to protect, and reports like these do not turn their hearts in the right direction.
the picture here is copied from the original article
Tuesday, February 16, 2010
Operation Mushtarak
Operation Mushtarak
Musktarak means 'together' in Dari Persian - and is the name of the join operation between Afghan and NATO forces to clear Marja, one of the main Taliban strongholds left in Afghanistan. Marja is a big opium producing town of almost 100,000 people, and had been cleared out previously in May of 2009. Unfortunately NATO forces had to withdraw after the battle and the Taiban slipped into the city and regained control. Estimates at the end of 2009 report that Marja was home to almost 1,000 enemy fighters and basically served as the insurgents’ capital. So far, Operation Mushtarak (launched on February 13th has been somewhat successful, and one of the biggest allied offensives in Afghanistan since 2001. Operation Mushtarak involves 15,000 troops, with about half of them Afghan and the rest mostly American and British soldiers. Today, the offensive resulted in Afghan and NATO forces in control of most of the area they planned to reclaim, but there is occasional fighting between militants and coalition troops who are moving from house to house. Clearing the town could take weeks because the danger of explosives to allied troops is extreme.
One of the biggest problems that has occurred are the civilians who have been harmed by the operation. At least 15 non-combatants have been killed, and 12 were killed when a coalition rocket missed its target, however Afghan officials say that three of the victims may have been militants. At least four NATO soldiers have died, one from a gun battle and three from an explosion. Finally, at least 30 insurgents have died. This operation was designed to win support from the local people, and accidents have not helped the situation. Many Marjan families have had to flee to the provincial capital Lashkar Gah. The government says that it is going to take care of them, though a local human rights group has voiced concerns saying that supplies have not been coming in from the government. In addition some refugees have reported that the Taliban tried to keep people from leaving the town.
Marine commanders say that “the insurgents have shown less resistance than had been anticipated” and that many insurgents are believed to have fled before the invasion took place. American forces have come under fire from snipers and attempted suicide attacks. The biggest obstacle to claiming the town are explosives, since many roads are mined and houses are booby-trapped. The roads into Marja are reported to be very dangerous. This time the allied NATO and Afghan forces are here to stay. The new doctrine is “clear, hold, and build” which should include rebuilding new schools and clinics along with road patrols for the area. A local government should help create jobs, but helping locals to understand and cooperate with these new changes. Fear of the Taliban is a powerful factor since locals are unsure that the Americans will stay forever and the Taliban will return. If they are always afraid of unseen insurgents who may or may not return, progress will not occur.
I believe that this war can only be ‘won’ by winning the minds and hearts of the Afghani people. If they are still afraid of insurgents, then that fear can be used against them to bring the country back into despair. Trust from the locals must be a primary goal of American forces, or nothing will be accomplished. NATO forces must have a drive to help or at least respect the people that they’re trying to save, and civilian casualties should be avoided at almost any cost. Obviously the lives of our own soldiers are extremely important, but if possible they should try to minimize civilian casualties. This is of course spoken from an observer who has no combat experience, and if we are actually doing that to the best of our ability, then I apologize. Hopefully this has been insightful!
source: http://www.economist.com/world/asia/displaystory.cfm?story_id=15539541
Musktarak means 'together' in Dari Persian - and is the name of the join operation between Afghan and NATO forces to clear Marja, one of the main Taliban strongholds left in Afghanistan. Marja is a big opium producing town of almost 100,000 people, and had been cleared out previously in May of 2009. Unfortunately NATO forces had to withdraw after the battle and the Taiban slipped into the city and regained control. Estimates at the end of 2009 report that Marja was home to almost 1,000 enemy fighters and basically served as the insurgents’ capital. So far, Operation Mushtarak (launched on February 13th has been somewhat successful, and one of the biggest allied offensives in Afghanistan since 2001. Operation Mushtarak involves 15,000 troops, with about half of them Afghan and the rest mostly American and British soldiers. Today, the offensive resulted in Afghan and NATO forces in control of most of the area they planned to reclaim, but there is occasional fighting between militants and coalition troops who are moving from house to house. Clearing the town could take weeks because the danger of explosives to allied troops is extreme.
One of the biggest problems that has occurred are the civilians who have been harmed by the operation. At least 15 non-combatants have been killed, and 12 were killed when a coalition rocket missed its target, however Afghan officials say that three of the victims may have been militants. At least four NATO soldiers have died, one from a gun battle and three from an explosion. Finally, at least 30 insurgents have died. This operation was designed to win support from the local people, and accidents have not helped the situation. Many Marjan families have had to flee to the provincial capital Lashkar Gah. The government says that it is going to take care of them, though a local human rights group has voiced concerns saying that supplies have not been coming in from the government. In addition some refugees have reported that the Taliban tried to keep people from leaving the town.
Marine commanders say that “the insurgents have shown less resistance than had been anticipated” and that many insurgents are believed to have fled before the invasion took place. American forces have come under fire from snipers and attempted suicide attacks. The biggest obstacle to claiming the town are explosives, since many roads are mined and houses are booby-trapped. The roads into Marja are reported to be very dangerous. This time the allied NATO and Afghan forces are here to stay. The new doctrine is “clear, hold, and build” which should include rebuilding new schools and clinics along with road patrols for the area. A local government should help create jobs, but helping locals to understand and cooperate with these new changes. Fear of the Taliban is a powerful factor since locals are unsure that the Americans will stay forever and the Taliban will return. If they are always afraid of unseen insurgents who may or may not return, progress will not occur.
I believe that this war can only be ‘won’ by winning the minds and hearts of the Afghani people. If they are still afraid of insurgents, then that fear can be used against them to bring the country back into despair. Trust from the locals must be a primary goal of American forces, or nothing will be accomplished. NATO forces must have a drive to help or at least respect the people that they’re trying to save, and civilian casualties should be avoided at almost any cost. Obviously the lives of our own soldiers are extremely important, but if possible they should try to minimize civilian casualties. This is of course spoken from an observer who has no combat experience, and if we are actually doing that to the best of our ability, then I apologize. Hopefully this has been insightful!
source: http://www.economist.com/world/asia/displaystory.cfm?story_id=15539541
Thursday, February 11, 2010
A Small Amount of Hope goes to Afghanistan
Today in Afghanistan the town of Now Zad moves back towards life as American troops have pushed many Taliban fighters our of the Helmand province of Afghanistan. Now Zad was once one of the most notorious battle zones in Afghanistan, but now the seeds of life are starting to return to it. It was almost completely destroyed by years of fighting between British forces and Taliban insurgents, so much that the center of the city is basically a pile of rubble. This entry is titled hope because after rebirth and growth come after destruction.
According to the Economist, “CAPTAIN Jason Brezler of the US Marine Corps had never imagined he might spend his tour of duty chasing truant children to school.” The captain strolls through the bazaar, completely unescorted except for one other marine and one Afghan policeman. He is even able to stop to chat with shopkeepers. Many of them have just started returning to a market that was empty for years, and this marketplace has just been recently secured by marines. To add to the recovery, even Afghan citizens are happy with the change. Muhammad Yunus, the first man to return to Now Zad is ready for the good times to come. "I have to thank the Americans more than my own father,” he says.
Yunus works as a day laborer helping to clear away rubble from the town. He is in a crew of 500 men, paid by the marines to make the town a better place. The town is slowly starting to become a better place; the video rental store has reopened (however it only has one movie), and the pharmacy appears to be well stocked, so well that it even stocks Viagra. Helmand is one of the more conflicted provinces of Afghanistan, and the actions of thousands of American troops has worked very well to push the Taliban out of most of the Helmand river valley. The surge of troops allows reclaimed territory to be accompanied by patrols by American and Afghan security forces.
The most important sign in my opinion, is the fact that the locals are very willing to cooperate with American and national Afghan forces. Many residents are still intimidated by the Taliban, however, due to the new surge of American troops residents are willing to be seen supporting the government and working with Americans. This is what the war is actually about, and it is of no importance if American troops cannot help the people of Afghanistan help themselves. The citizens of Now Zad are returning back to their town, even though it is prohibited by the Taliban. Any time when American and Afghan troops help civilians return to their homes and prosper is a good time for Afghanistan in my opinion.
One important thing to take away from this news is the fact that it is only one small town in a province of Afghanistan. It is evidence that there is good being done and that coalition forces are making progress. Let us hope that they only make more progress in the same direction.
source:http://www.economist.com/world/asia/displaystory.cfm?story_id=15497693
According to the Economist, “CAPTAIN Jason Brezler of the US Marine Corps had never imagined he might spend his tour of duty chasing truant children to school.” The captain strolls through the bazaar, completely unescorted except for one other marine and one Afghan policeman. He is even able to stop to chat with shopkeepers. Many of them have just started returning to a market that was empty for years, and this marketplace has just been recently secured by marines. To add to the recovery, even Afghan citizens are happy with the change. Muhammad Yunus, the first man to return to Now Zad is ready for the good times to come. "I have to thank the Americans more than my own father,” he says.
Yunus works as a day laborer helping to clear away rubble from the town. He is in a crew of 500 men, paid by the marines to make the town a better place. The town is slowly starting to become a better place; the video rental store has reopened (however it only has one movie), and the pharmacy appears to be well stocked, so well that it even stocks Viagra. Helmand is one of the more conflicted provinces of Afghanistan, and the actions of thousands of American troops has worked very well to push the Taliban out of most of the Helmand river valley. The surge of troops allows reclaimed territory to be accompanied by patrols by American and Afghan security forces.
The most important sign in my opinion, is the fact that the locals are very willing to cooperate with American and national Afghan forces. Many residents are still intimidated by the Taliban, however, due to the new surge of American troops residents are willing to be seen supporting the government and working with Americans. This is what the war is actually about, and it is of no importance if American troops cannot help the people of Afghanistan help themselves. The citizens of Now Zad are returning back to their town, even though it is prohibited by the Taliban. Any time when American and Afghan troops help civilians return to their homes and prosper is a good time for Afghanistan in my opinion.
One important thing to take away from this news is the fact that it is only one small town in a province of Afghanistan. It is evidence that there is good being done and that coalition forces are making progress. Let us hope that they only make more progress in the same direction.
source:http://www.economist.com/world/asia/displaystory.cfm?story_id=15497693
Wednesday, February 10, 2010
Introduction!
Hello everyone !
This is my blog about the ongoing War in Afghanistan.
Who am I? Just a college student who wants to talk about things that he finds interesting related to the war. I must admit that I do not have an extremely strong historical background. Furthermore, I am also new to blogging so I hope that this experience is as enjoyable to readers as it is to write!
What to expect from this blog:
To end this first post, I'll randomly add a picture that I found when I used google's image search and seached Afghanistan.

See you next time!
This is my blog about the ongoing War in Afghanistan.
Who am I? Just a college student who wants to talk about things that he finds interesting related to the war. I must admit that I do not have an extremely strong historical background. Furthermore, I am also new to blogging so I hope that this experience is as enjoyable to readers as it is to write!
What to expect from this blog:
- Discussion of current events happening in Afghanistan
- Discussion on things related to the war in Afghanistan
- Possible cultural/historical backgrounds of groups of people in Afghanistan
- Any interesting tidbits that are found along the way!
To end this first post, I'll randomly add a picture that I found when I used google's image search and seached Afghanistan.

See you next time!
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)