Random Special Forces
The provocative title of this week’s entry comes from an inquiry into the practices of the United States Special Forces in Afghanistan. After nine years of fighting most of the work that the Special Forces have done has been out of the public spotlight. A new high profile investigation is bringing the heat and pointing the public eye in their direction. Both Afghan and American officials are investigating the aftermath of a raid in February carried out by US Special Forces. Five Afghan civilians died in the raid, and it is alleged that their deaths were covered up. The raid was led by US Special Forces and they were backed up by Afghan troops. Three of the five dead civilians were women, and the Special Forces are charged with tampering with the bodies to conceal the way that they died. The US military has accepted responsibility for the deaths on February 12th. (Link here - http://lat.ms/ad1n5d), and even though they had initially blamed the deaths on insurgents, senior officials met with family members of the dead civilians to apologize. The underlying charge that accompanied the deaths of the civilians is that bullets were taken from the bodies of the corpses to cover up their deaths, but United States officials say that they are unjustifiable charges.
There is a new investigation that has just been opened to compare the differences between the findings of the initial American inquiry (classified) and the findings of the Afghan government. This LA times article (http://www.latimes.com/news/nationworld/world/asia/la-fg-afghan-special-forces9-2010apr09%2C0%2C7174357.story) says that US Special Forces are very much linked to civilian deaths and casualties in Afghanistan. Apparently, Special Forces account for a “disproportionate share” of civilian casualties caused by western troops; however, there are no precise figures to prove this point since Special Forces missions are secret. The US commander on the ground in Afghanistan, General Stanley McChrystal believes that Afghan civilian casualties are detrimental to the war effort because they turn the people of Afghanistan away from the help that the United States is trying to provide. I believe he is absolutely right, and the United States cannot keep killing the people of Afghanistan. The bottom line is that killing them obviously makes them unhappy, and the way that the Afghan people see it, they can either be oppressed by the Taliban or killed by the people who were sent to Afghanistan to help them. This is not the case, but I’m sure that some people think exactly that, that they have no options at all.

General McChrystal
Ever since he took command, General McChrystal has changed the rules of engagement in Afghanistan to try and relieve civilian casualties. Special Forces are given more freedom than regular troops due to their mission of hunting down Taliban fighters. The Special Forces have earned an awesome sort of respect from Afghani fighters. Whenever they are spoken of it tends to be in whispers, and they strike fear into the hearts of many would be attackers. That may have been a little bit of creative description, but the Special Forces have earned their names in Afghanistan. They are secretive even among their own comrades and have beards and Afghan looking clothes. The LA Times says that they also ‘react explosively’ if anyone tries to take their picture.
The US military raid in question was supposed to be a simple mission. It was made to sound as if it were a “successful instant of Western raiders swooping down on wanted militants.” NATO (at the time) described the men who were killed as armed insurgents who had fired on friendly troops. They also said that the 3 women were dead before the coalition troops arrived. Two months of investigating changed the story significantly. The two slain Afghan citizens were ordinary civilians; one was an Afghan police official and the other was a district prosecutor. Local leaders identified the two men, and the others were a teenage girl and two pregnant women. The two pregnant women were mothers of a total of 16 children. Canadian Brigadier General Eric Tremblay spoke for NATO saying, "We deeply regret the outcome of this operation, accept responsibility for our actions that night, and know that this loss will be felt forever by the families.” This kind of news really puts the integrity of our own Special Forces into question. Why would they want to kill ordinary civilians? Even if the men had been armed, and even IF they had fired on coalition troops, there is no reason I can think of to kill pregnant women. I am saying this sitting safely at home in my apartment, but it is hard to imagine the circumstances necessary to facilitate the necessity for that kind of slaughter.
The raid occurred on a family compound in the village of Khatabeh and was tampered with to conceal the circumstances of the civilians’ deaths. "By the time we got there, there was a foreign guy guarding the bodies, and they wouldn't let us come near," said Azizdin Wardak, chief of police in Paktia. Reports were made that coalition forces removed bullets from the walls of the compound, collected their casings, and washed the ground. That sounds very much like a coverup, but military officials say that that could also be the legitimate means to reconstruct the events on the night of the raid. An Afghan investigator was quoted by a British newspaper saying that US Special Forces were trying to extract bullets from the bodies of their victims. The unidentified investigator apparently interviewed a relative of the deceased who described a coalition soldier standing over one of the bodies after the raid with a knife. General McChrystal’s spokesperson said there was no forensic evidence or any eyewitness testimony to support the claims of the unknown investigator. So far there had been no official evidence of a coverup, but the incident remained controversial due to the fact that the military suggested that the women had been killed ‘execution-style’ by insurgents or by an ‘honor killing’ by their own relatives. The military had also said that they died at a time not during the raid by Special Forces. There was a large gathering in the family compound, which was mistaken as a gathering of insurgents instead of the simple celebration that it was.
Since the raid General McChrystal has limited night time operations due to the increased chances of false identification of suspected insurgents. Night raids are extremely effective to strike at ones enemy, but many innocent people could be caught in the crossfire. Rural parts of Afghanistan commonly have weapons due to the volatile nature of living out in the country, and especially in a country like Afghanistan. Anyone who hears a gunshot at night would want to defend themselves, and this is a likely cause of many unfortunate civilian casualties over the years. I think that this is a sound decision and even though it hurts Special Forces operating capabilities it is definitely worth the sacrifice. Preventing the killing of innocent civilians is just as important if not more important than killing the insurgents. The death of innocent civilians should outweigh the death of a few insurgents who are hiding with the civilians.
Afghan Villager speaks to US Special Forces on Patrol
Many Afghans do not trust the Special Forces after NATO airstrikes have killed many civilians on incorrectly planned attacks. Civilians have been hurt because coalition forces have not followed proper protocols set in place to prevent civilian deaths. In February a NATO airstrike killed 27 people, some of which were women and children. NATO surveillance had observed three vehicles closely following each other heading for Khandahar, the southern city that is regarded by the Taliban as its spiritual home. The small convoy was believed to be an insurgent group preparing to attack coalition forces, but turned out to be only innocent travelers. Killing the people that we went out to protect is a huge issue. I believe the problem is that some people really care about the protocols and understand the need to protect innocent civilians. There are obviously those who do not care enough or care at all about the people that we have come to protect. NATO airstrikes are fine when they’re used properly, properly in this context means against a tactical or strategic target, and more specifically one that is not in a location full of innocent people who would suffer for the bad choices of one single individual.
This is becoming way too long to be a blog article, there’s almost enough information for three blogs here! I hope it wasn’t too boring because it is a topic of deep discussion and one that I believe must be solved in order to help the people of Afghanistan.
Well – until next week.
Source: http://www.latimes.com/news/nationworld/world/asia/la-fg-afghan-special-forces9-2010apr09,0,7174357.story?page=1